Prop shaft rope cutter

[Jason Flare]

Originally Posted by Steady Hand

I am curious, and I would like to see some cost comparisons on these products.
If anyone reading this has done some recent analysis, comparing the retail prices for the same size shaft but different prop line cutters, please post it or share or send me a PM. Note that the prices for these items can vary significantly based on prop shaft size, so it is important to quote same size.

Steady,

The only comparison I have is for the 1 1/2" Shaftshark vs. the 1 1/2" PropProtector. Defender has the SS for $439.99 + shipping, the PP is $310.39 + $15.00 shipping.

Wanting a line cutter in 2003, I contacted SS and they didn't get back to me. I found PP out of Canada and bought one from them. This, BTW was before I used the Internet and relied on magazine ads.

Mrs. Flare has told me that there are tests, (or testimonials,) where the smooth rather than the serrated edge performs well.

ETA: Both prices are for the two piece discs that can be installed without removing the prop.

[Safari38LH]

I have Spurs which have worked great for the last 6 or so years we have used them. We have never had a problem when motoring. I do think that when sailing they tend to catch lobster pots that would otherwise slip by.

[Ziggy]

If you don't need the split disk feature, Shaft Razor for 1.5" shaft costs $313 from the manufacturer (The Evolution Company Inc. - Home of The Evolution Marine Shaft System)

[daletournier]

Shadt shark seems like the one for me, don't want to haul the boat until I need to.
Cheers Dale.

Sent from my vivo Y35 using Cruisers Sailing Forum mobile app