Cruisers Forum
 


Reply
  This discussion is proudly sponsored by:
Please support our sponsors and let them know you heard about their products on Cruisers Forums. Advertise Here
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Rate Thread Display Modes
Old 15-03-2013, 05:48   #31
Registered User
 
svHyLyte's Avatar

Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Tampa Bay area, USA
Boat: Beneteau First 42
Posts: 3,961
Images: 25
Re: Doppler Effect or Not?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Richard_W View Post
Interesting, and simple explanation even without the formulas ... the frequency shifts of the source and the receiver created by moving medium cancel each other.

Right ...
Yup, exactly right--its the relative speeds of transmitter and receiver that determine Doppler effect frequency shifts. No formulas needed. Only attenuation--the decay of the sound--will be effected by wind speed/direction, faster up-wind than down, which is why one can hear sounds from further off when down wind of the transmitter--like waves crashing on a breakwater, eh?

FWIW...
__________________
"It is not so much for its beauty that the Sea makes a claim upon men's hearts, as for that subtle something, that quality of air, that emanation from the waves, that so wonderfully renews a weary spirit."
svHyLyte is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-03-2013, 09:25   #32
Registered User

Join Date: May 2012
Location: Central California
Boat: Catalina 30
Posts: 880
Re: Doppler Effect or Not?

Consider an observer (not the listener) watching the emitter and receiver travelling from right to left. Let's say the observer can see the sound waves.

It would appear to the observer that the waves from the emitter are squeezed together on the left of the emitter and the waves would be stretched out on the right of the emitter.

In absolute terms, the frequency on the left of the emitter is 'higher', but the listener is also moving to the left, 'catching' the waves a bit of time later each wave, so the 'higher' frequency would be perceived by the listener as lower than they are in absolute terms.

Now consider a vacuum. No sound waves. Is the medium absolutely important or absolutely unimportant?
__________________
Bill
...........................................
You can't buy happiness, but you can buy ribeye.
jongleur is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-03-2013, 09:47   #33
Registered User

Join Date: May 2012
Location: Central California
Boat: Catalina 30
Posts: 880
Re: Doppler Effect or Not?

I hit post too quickly. I meant to add:

Now, if both the emitter and listener are stationary and the medium (air) is moving from left to right, is that not the same as the emitter and listener moving right to left through the medium?
__________________
Bill
...........................................
You can't buy happiness, but you can buy ribeye.
jongleur is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-03-2013, 09:57   #34
Moderator Emeritus
 
Paul Elliott's Avatar

Cruisers Forum Supporter

Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 4,663
Images: 4
Re: Doppler Effect or Not?

Quote:
Originally Posted by jongleur View Post
Consider an observer (not the listener) watching the emitter and receiver travelling from right to left. Let's say the observer can see the sound waves.

It would appear to the observer that the waves from the emitter are squeezed together on the left of the emitter and the waves would be stretched out on the right of the emitter.

In absolute terms, the frequency on the left of the emitter is 'higher', but the listener is also moving to the left, 'catching' the waves a bit of time later each wave, so the 'higher' frequency would be perceived by the listener as lower than they are in absolute terms.
But you aren't describing "absolute terms". You are describing a system with a third reference point, one which is moving relative to the emitter.

Quote:
Now consider a vacuum. No sound waves. Is the medium absolutely important or absolutely unimportant?
It is absolutely important that there be a medium. With a medium, any medium, the density of that medium will have no effect on frequency when the emitter and detector are fixed (relative to each other).

About the density of the medium, here's a thought experiment: Say I have a ham transmitter, and you have a receiver. I transmit on 14.3MHz. The signal leaves my radio, runs through 20 ft of coaxial cable, through my antenna, into the air, bounces off the ionosphere and down to your antenna, through your coax, and and finally into your receiver. The propagation velocity of most coaxial cable is between 0.66c and 0.88c (c = speed of light in vacuum). The Vprop of radio signals in air is about 0.999c. As the signal moves through these different media, the speed of propagation changes, as does the physical wavelength, (the vProp determines the wavelength). At no point would we say that the frequency changes, because it really doesn't. The physical wavelength changes, and the phase changes (relative to some uniform reference).

You can probably treat the moving air (wind) in a similar manner to a more, or less dense, medium. It will affect the Vprop, but not the frequency.
__________________
Paul Elliott, S/V VALIS - Pacific Seacraft 44 #16 - Friday Harbor, WA
www.sailvalis.com
Paul Elliott is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-03-2013, 09:59   #35
Moderator Emeritus
 
Paul Elliott's Avatar

Cruisers Forum Supporter

Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 4,663
Images: 4
Re: Doppler Effect or Not?

Quote:
Originally Posted by jongleur View Post
I hit post too quickly. I meant to add:

Now, if both the emitter and listener are stationary and the medium (air) is moving from left to right, is that not the same as the emitter and listener moving right to left through the medium?
Yes. For the purposes of this discussion they are exactly the same.

I think that most of us are in violent agreement.

And this has little to do with sailing. So what? It's a fun discussion.
__________________
Paul Elliott, S/V VALIS - Pacific Seacraft 44 #16 - Friday Harbor, WA
www.sailvalis.com
Paul Elliott is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-03-2013, 10:33   #36
Moderator Emeritus
 
David M's Avatar

Cruisers Forum Supporter

Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Eastern Tennessee
Boat: Research vessel for a university, retired now.
Posts: 10,406
Re: Doppler Effect or Not?

Since the medium that the sound is traveling on is also itself traveling towards the listener, then the number of cycles that pass the listeners ear per second would be greater....more cycles per amount of time passing a particular point would be a higher frequency.

Imagine two ticker tapes with equally spaced dots on them. You look at one ticker tape that is stopped and the second ticker tape whose dots are moving towards you. The second tape is going to have more dots per second passing your eyes.

Sound is not limited to the grid of space like electromagnetic waves are. Sounds medium is not limited to standing still with respect to two fixed points. If sound and EM waves were limited like this then what Paul is saying would be true. No offense Paul....just trying to set up the argument.
__________________
David

Life begins where land ends.
David M is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-03-2013, 11:13   #37
Moderator Emeritus
 
Paul Elliott's Avatar

Cruisers Forum Supporter

Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 4,663
Images: 4
Re: Doppler Effect or Not?

Quote:
Originally Posted by David M View Post
Since the medium that the sound is traveling on is also itself traveling towards the listener, then the number of cycles that pass the listeners ear per second would be greater....more cycles per amount of time passing a particular point would be a higher frequency.

Imagine two ticker tapes with equally spaced dots on them. You look at one ticker tape that is stopped and the second ticker tape whose dots are moving towards you. The second tape is going to have more dots per second passing your eyes.

Sound is not limited to the grid of space like electromagnetic waves are. Sounds medium is not limited to standing still with respect to two fixed points. If sound and EM waves were limited like this then what Paul is saying would be true. No offense Paul....just trying to set up the argument.
But -- the medium is moving past the sound source as well as the listener. With sound, the effect of the moving medium is to change the propagation velocity, not the perceived frequency.

I'm going to try an experiment with my shopvac (as a blower), some hoses, and a tiny speaker inside the hose. I'll bet that the frequency of the sound I hear when the air leaves the hose will be unchanged. In fact, I will put a constriction at the hose exit, so the air velocity will be different at my ear than it was at the speaker. I predict that even then the pitch will be unchanged.

David, if I understand you correctly, you are saying that for either of these cases the frequency I hear will be different than what I put into the speaker.

At least we're not arguing about relativistic effects. That gets (to me, anyway) non-intuitive very quickly. Example: If you're in a spaceship moving away from Earth at almost the speed of light, and you shine your flashlight forwards. How long does it take for the light to reach the nose of the ship? Point the flashlight back at Earth. How long until your signal is seen back on Earth?

Let's stick with sound, OK?
__________________
Paul Elliott, S/V VALIS - Pacific Seacraft 44 #16 - Friday Harbor, WA
www.sailvalis.com
Paul Elliott is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-03-2013, 11:21   #38
Moderator Emeritus
 
Paul Elliott's Avatar

Cruisers Forum Supporter

Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 4,663
Images: 4
Re: Doppler Effect or Not?

Quote:
Originally Posted by David M View Post
Imagine two ticker tapes with equally spaced dots on them. You look at one ticker tape that is stopped and the second ticker tape whose dots are moving towards you. The second tape is going to have more dots per second passing your eyes.
But in this analogy, we have a blank ticker tape, at one end a source (punching machine), and at the other end a detector (your eyes). Regardless of what the tape speed may be (as long as it is constant), if the source punches one hole per second, you will detect one hole per second. Depending on the tape speed, these holes will be further apart or closer together (wavelength), but they will still be passing your eyeball at one hole per second (frequency).
__________________
Paul Elliott, S/V VALIS - Pacific Seacraft 44 #16 - Friday Harbor, WA
www.sailvalis.com
Paul Elliott is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-03-2013, 11:26   #39
Moderator Emeritus
 
Paul Elliott's Avatar

Cruisers Forum Supporter

Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 4,663
Images: 4
Re: Doppler Effect or Not?

I really enjoy a good-natured argument, especially when I'm right! Even when I'm wrong (hypothetically speaking), I get to learn something.
__________________
Paul Elliott, S/V VALIS - Pacific Seacraft 44 #16 - Friday Harbor, WA
www.sailvalis.com
Paul Elliott is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-03-2013, 12:01   #40
Registered User
 
svHyLyte's Avatar

Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Tampa Bay area, USA
Boat: Beneteau First 42
Posts: 3,961
Images: 25
Re: Doppler Effect or Not?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Paul Elliott View Post
But in this analogy, we have a blank ticker tape, at one end a source (punching machine), and at the other end a detector (your eyes). Regardless of what the tape speed may be (as long as it is constant), if the source punches one hole per second, you will detect one hole per second. Depending on the tape speed, these holes will be further apart or closer together (wavelength), but they will still be passing your eyeball at one hole per second (frequency).
Good analogy Paul. And if the "detector" is moving toward the tape punch it/he will see the holes more frequently (so the frequency will be percieved to increase); or, if away from the tape punch less frequently (so the frequency will be percieved to decrease); or, if away at the same speed as the tape speed, at no frequency at all!
__________________
"It is not so much for its beauty that the Sea makes a claim upon men's hearts, as for that subtle something, that quality of air, that emanation from the waves, that so wonderfully renews a weary spirit."
svHyLyte is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-03-2013, 12:14   #41
Moderator Emeritus
 
Paul Elliott's Avatar

Cruisers Forum Supporter

Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 4,663
Images: 4
Re: Doppler Effect or Not?

Quote:
Originally Posted by svHyLyte View Post
or, if away at the same speed as the tape speed, at no frequency at all!
And if if you go away from the source faster than the speed of the tape (speed of sound), the music plays backwards until you reach the beginning of the song.

I like the punched-tape analogy. Thanks, David! (Although here I'm mixing up paper tape, magnetic tape, and sound.)
__________________
Paul Elliott, S/V VALIS - Pacific Seacraft 44 #16 - Friday Harbor, WA
www.sailvalis.com
Paul Elliott is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-03-2013, 12:19   #42
Registered User

Join Date: May 2012
Location: Central California
Boat: Catalina 30
Posts: 880
Re: Doppler Effect or Not?

So, if the emitter is moving at the speed of sound, mach I, the forward waves will be perceived by the emitter as not moving at all.

As someone asked, where would the waves be 'buffered'? Are they buffered and then spent in a boom or whip crack? Is that a different frequency for the listener, or is it the sum of all frequencies?
__________________
Bill
...........................................
You can't buy happiness, but you can buy ribeye.
jongleur is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-03-2013, 12:23   #43
Registered User

Join Date: Feb 2012
Posts: 2,441
Re: Doppler Effect or Not?

It's interesting looking at the nature of the posts.

Some people clearly think that assertion is sufficient, and some of the asserters seem to think assertions have explanatory power.

Others have no interest in assertion but are very interested in explanation.

The asserters tend to get impatient and angry with the explainers.
Andrew Troup is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-03-2013, 12:34   #44
Moderator Emeritus
 
Paul Elliott's Avatar

Cruisers Forum Supporter

Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 4,663
Images: 4
Re: Doppler Effect or Not?

Quote:
Originally Posted by jongleur View Post
So, if the emitter is moving at the speed of sound, mach I, the forward waves will be perceived by the emitter as not moving at all.

As someone asked, where would the waves be 'buffered'? Are they buffered and then spent in a boom or whip crack? Is that a different frequency for the listener, or is it the sum of all frequencies?
Let's ignore all those difficult real-world effects like turbulance, and assume isotropic radiators (infinitely small and radiating equally in all directions) and all that simplifying stuff, I think that the pressure variations (sound) in the forward direction would effectively cancel each other out. The energy delivered on one half-cycle would be returned on the alternate half-cycle, and so no power would be coupled. That's just in the straight-ahead direction. In all other directions, the pressure waves would propagate out at the speed of sound. Here's a nice image I just found:

[IMG]http://www.cruisersforum.com/forums/ kXISYeGhwkGhQTHy8gLygqLCwsFh49NTAqNSYrLCkBCQoKDgwO Fw8PFioeHxwsKiw1LC8sNSk1LCo1NTU1NTQpNikpLSwsNTA1NS o1NTUqNCkpNTUyMDUvNTU1NCs1LP/AABEIAKQBMwMBIgACEQEDEQH/xAAbAAEAAgMBAQAAAAAAAAAAAAAABAUBAwYCB//EAEoQAAIBAwIEAwQGBAkKBwAAAAECAwAREgQhBQYTMSJBURQyY XEHIzNCgZEVUmJyJENTVHOCk6GxFmNkkqKy0tPi8DREg5TC0dT/xAAYAQEBAQEBAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAQIDBP/EAC0RAQABAgIGCQUAAAAAAAAAAAABAhEDIQQSMVFhoRNBcYGRw dHh8CIyM1Kx/9oADAMBAAIRAxEAPwD7jSlKBSlKBSlKBUHjfF00sEk8mWESlmx F2sPID8vh62G9Tb1F4pp3kiKxuqsSu7rmtsgWDLcZAqGW1x37i tU2vGtsEPTcyRlGeX6hV6fimaIIeooZCjqxVgcgLg962tzDphe +ohFlRjeSP3ZNkbv2bax8/KuZg5CkQXjkjjCaqPUQ6cZnTx4oyOg+8My7NsAAQth3vBn+i+X odJNQhvptPCzSB9mi1J1JK2PuksVA+6AO9euMLR5n8ltnV82M3 nc7aDj+mdsU1ELNZjZZEJ8Gz7A38J7+nnUPh3NkWobUrCrSez4 boY2WbOPqp0mDWNxtvbeuam+jeWTZ5Y1BbiZbEMTbWqAMb2uUN/mLdqveWOWpdNJqJJJEYzjT+GNWAXowrDe7E3va/bapXh6PTTMxXebbON/QiZ3Nei58ikOjtHIq63LpsxjAVkvlG4yuG2O1iCdgb1aaTmGF1 jydI2lAKRu8eZBBYWAO91GW3lVBqfo7VkmUS45ahZoSAfqBn1H QC+4Znn9NnHpWeK8jPLrY9QkkarHJpZAgRgzdESIRIwPjOLjFi DjjYWuxNqo0aqcqrbfb07uJeXQR8w6ZgGXUQkMrsCJIyCsf2jA g2IXzPYedbBxqDwfXRfWXCeNPGQwQhd/F4iF28zbvXN6/6PhJFrohLiuqYtGLEiAsUkkA33Dyx5G1q9DkhhJBIjJE0chkfB pmzzlSWVW6jHqBzGO4BDEMCMbHn0eB+8+HD5Hd2LmveOcfi0ka yS3xZ402F7ZsFyPoqglifQHzsDkcehOpOmDDqiPqFfRSbD8Tub eg+V6/jvLj6oyrIy9IwvGiqzKSXsX6u1ipKpa24x877aOB8t6mLUJNNN HI3s0enkIDgt03dlkF/Nsxf4g977SKcLo7zV9Xy3mZ3SjzYBJqYzBIG0yqxBMQ6ivcq0d 23BsRvbcWqd+nIQcXljjkCl2jeSPNAou+QB+75nt+FQ9fyyJNZ DqQ2PTRkkSx+tAZZIrm+2EgLdj3qk4hyHK+rbULLEBlqCqBWUf XaboEtibFwwuXtdhYXAVRWqacGq16rZc93f5ma9Tm7TNMsSSxy ZI7l0khKIqBWu9muLq4INrW722qTHzDpmCldRCQ+eJEkZDYDJ8 bHfFdz6DvXKan6O5JIdPEZY1EWil0rOobJi6Igcdth0luCdwzC/rvHJE/VWcyxdXrySsoD9IBtKNIAu+VwAG+Pba163OFo9sq9/t48kvO51EHGoHKhJomLqGUK6EspBIZQDuCFY3+B9Krm5rAk1MZ hkDaZFkNzGOojXKtF4tx4WFzaxFqq+WuR5dNJp3Mq/VRCOQJnabGPpoWVjiGF2IcAGxKm4N6tuJ8siXWQakMF6aski2+ 1TJZI1JvsElUP2Pc1zmnBpqmNa8W28ffzXNu13MkUUUjv9pFC0 zwB4zMqqubDENa4Hne3bfetmi5ggl6YEiCSWNJFiZ06uLLmPBe/a/5Guc4nyAZJNWwZD7QJTGz9W8Ly6b2V7KGwIxscrX8vQjzo+QJF kiLTLgr6eVsAwfqQ6U6XFT2wNw3a/ced630ej6n359nJM9y913N2njKASJIWmSFhHJETGWyOTgsLAYN sLn0BsbauH866eYx9NrrJHLKHLRhVSNsSWBbIX73tsO9qp4uRZ Vh0kWUF9JPp36gVg80cHUxD+jWk7XIBv62EJ/ozmfTxwPPGFj0s2mDKr5HN0kV7HbvGoK37E77VuMPRrWmvr5Z5/xL1bnbjjcFkPWitISEOaeMhgpC772YhdvM271NBrjxyMweB0ZI mSVpZDG07Zl5IpJVbqMeoH6IvkNmKsD4bN2C15MSmiLalV282a UpXMKUpQKUpQKUpQKUpQKUpQKUqp1+oEjMhbGKMXmYmwPhyEV/IWKsx9LD7xsGyXiLuSsCggXvK/2QI2IWxykYHyFhsbsCLVWmZXO82o1B8xpskjBHezxYjY3GJkY7 73tcbpUDIplU4NYRaUADLbwiRdrm25U+BQN/dyGubJmwbKRgB9RpmMccQI26svhY7X9LjtHteg8+wr/MNT/aw/8APrKTKhAE0+nJIsuqyeNidrZSEk322EgPb1sa94tPfccNU33D L1SD2OUpxub7kkA+vrUq7RqGvjGw97qtqNK4Pk5fxxg7+IeHff LsQt4uIMjBZ1xvsJF+yY+Q33Rj+qdvIMxqyrno7IrjAlFH1umP jCLb3objxIQNktYgGwVgVM3h+owYRFskYZQve9180y3uVFiDfx KfPFjQWlKUoFKUoFKUoFqUpQKUpQKWpSgWpSsXoM0tVdNx2IEh WMhBsRCrSFT2sxQEKdj3Iqufm9bkKqCxI+tmiBBH6wj6hH4799 qDorUrm/8AKGdv4vD/ANDXS3+N+klv76fp6Ue88aD1l02rjX5ZPYX+FB0lKodNx6Rzih 0spAuQk5VyO1+mUNu47t+O9S/0u6/aaeVfigEq/lGS/wDs/nQWdKjaTiUUtwjgke8vZ1/**+Jex7gdqkA0GaUpQKUpQKUpQKUpQKUpQa55Aqlj2UEn5AXNU GhjL9BG7ke1S/FywZF33sJGJHmOgoPfey5iQnSagAEkwzAAC5JMbAADzrVpnB1U pBBDQacgjcEdTUbj1HiX8x60EVtUSXkWxdnOngB7DEkOxH76Ss d91hUbGtbRpg+QZoYjgFvvqJiwVjIR795GCWOxbO4IC2xw/wBzQ37hpFe/8oIpVcH9rIPfzuDWIdtPp2PZNQer+91ZImJ9frmBJ+BPlQScWU qjatYXIGMMfQCDyUKsil2FxbuL+QFa0uhkdUCyxnKWOO+EyG56 iL+swDWPfJCpJAvTShY4+lNp3kkIs5EWazsRiXL2wGVuzkW7Gw ANeuEQsszBzcpCgbuwXKWR0jLfeKpYX77g/eoI08ohdWQgoq9WMj3fZ2dBOm33EDRyLbtsBsLH1rB01nUf+WK amO3cIS7PGPn09QoH6rgbWvUPU/8Ag9Nf+bzE/uezNuf2bmP4Xx87VZa9rPvtho5siT7tylsj5Xwf54n0NBfIdq9 VG4cpEMYIsQiAg+RxG1qk0ClKUClKUClKUClKUClKUGjW6xY0L Nc7gADuzMQqqPiSQPTfew3rleIatpvFK4EZBZVUgqyC12VTZXU XF5pLRiwshBD1Yc1xscAATcTABb3MhiNgLb3MfXA+fqRVRxWUd cEkdJjG6Ff5L+DhDHb0/hZFtw0i4+JkuEeSS9lKg2HgWX6xrdgY42U4iw+5pytuxIW9SkE xA8U42HaPWkWAtiFi6CgD1Cjt23vUnR9MZXMwjLNj7KH6ZF9i7 QXl6lsci5Bve3mTJy0/3X1t/KzcQY/k1wfyoKz2Yj3p5E+Lw8TVQPVm9oxA+JIqdp+HyFQ0bCVT5xavV Le2xtkXBPlbJbHufS24OZPFnnhcdMyhRKRvfIL5drXs3fIX3Mf WqgmXo265dMwnnHdczPbb3L4lt72x7mghurMVSVrsT4U10ULoz WP2ckOK5d7DdrX8PpsiiKEKC+mc7Kpbq6Zz5Kmdrdj4B02sNvO 1zrjGI2M2HTsMupbG1+xB27229bVVSEjQqJgxdkCqCfrDIfsgC d+pfA3vsRckWJAb2VZWEeoiUSAMUYG4IFrtC4s6EeG42IPYkDK tgkeC2bZxEgB29+Mk2UP+styBl3F/FcXYa+JZYwKbGXqwkW/ZZTMw9B0+oP6wHmKncSKdKTq+5g+ff3cTl237XoJVKicJD9GLq e/00zva+WIy7bd71LoFKUoFKUoFKUoFKUoPMi3BB7Guc0rdIRsT9 hfTS/0Zx6Up8u3SY+QEsna1q6Wq/X6Vg3VQZG2MibfWJvsL7ZAm48jdge4ICvm0pDvGCFJfrwMdlD9 5Iye+5zJ88ZmsPCazHKLO/TZ4pftYgMnikti4ZBuQRa4FyCLgMHuMKyiMLZpNOLBWQP1oSvZ WS2fgIABHjXa42LVqwZvrEJl2sNRpTGJCB92aNvBJbftuCTZV3 oNkerOP1etgMYHeUBpFt3DN1FFx8Vv63r1GiyRmOIs0bXMs7/xgPvhG2zLDbIeFV7HYCoja5y12ClhbxNoNYWBHxBI2PmCRWNV1 HF52CR37zhEj72BWEMzStfYB2tfEhTtcNsq+0TC3uEAD0EKuru xHpMyIgHmqE+opMOsHP87ZY1H+jITm58wGVpiD/nYxsTetjAYHNXWFz4swTPqmI7FFFwpA92way2xRRvZ6DStkZZN nbYL36adwm21yd2I7mw3CrQTlrNKUClKUClKUClKUClKUClKUG jWaRZFKt2NjtsQVIZWB8iGAIPqK5riGgZLh1DISTfFzGSe5sgZ 9O58yuUbXa6gtXWUoPnf6Mx8cTug8mF2Q/KfTXYLubC0ZIb1Jy3Q6+fssvUA2Ij1CWXz3eWRpC3qpQbnvtY9 fPwWJmLYYse7xlo3PzaMgnufPzqNNwAkgiZjbsJkhlA+BLKHI/rA/GgpSmoPv6ed/3tRMAR6FUxUj5g9/St0c08aWEZhS++EUEZubn3ppyC3c5YnfuD2qT/kp/m9A3z0gH+D16i5cZTdYtAp9V0xB/ueggx6izgvNCZF7MztqpFuLXSKNUWO4PvAfDzFp+mictlHG7Pa wm1ZC2B/UjUBh644pfzPpMj0GoAxE0SL6RQ2I8ziWdlB+an5V6/Qt/tJppPhl01/KEJf5G4oNXUiga8sheZgfVnt6RxICVX3ew38ORY717SB5iDKMI wVYRd2Yg5K0hGwsQCEF9wCSewmaPQRxAiNFW/fEAFvix7k7nc771IoFKV5L0HqlKUClYJoDQZpSlApSlArBNZqm 5rdvZmCytEzNGodFdrXddmEZDhCLhmUgqpJBFrgJOp4YrPmjNF Idi8ePiA2AcMCrW8ri48iL7wNRw2TLJ4IpG85IHeCU/BvO238ofLba9cj+n9ShWRTKqpDr9vHqopJEl0+LxucGdAryYls bCN+4uTph5l1Uk0byMGDSaNRHi/TJXWayF3jZSPFjFAxJuCHHhtjYOu9nb+Q1/wD7lP8A9Fb9LwyQG6QxQt/KyM08w8rC9vXbxkfs1zWm5x1bdAMY0EracSuYmHReSDUyTaezN bKJ4YBc9usAR6wZ/pF1gWNvqkLwROQ0TWV2XRswUZ3YX1GpF9vsiLExuSH0TScMCNm xMklrZva4B8lAAVBsNgBewvc71Nrm+F6zV+1vBK6sI7SdRY8Vk ikQLGvc2cSpOT+yg/W26QUClKUClKUClKUClKoeb+Jz6eJZNOubK92ixyMiKrSOq23D FUa3fcjY9iF9SuOg51J1EpJDafDSDT9MAtM+pnm06tle2JeEWO wxa5r030gRujdOOe5hWVSohzKFZc2QO1rxtA4IO18bXDC4dfSu Og+kSIKbxag4JIcisV3MUUMrGyNYXWdGvsB4u1qsNbx+VtKJtN GSzSBQrYZlFkKyNCCwWQ4q7IMrMLEXFgQ6GlcRw3nVjMQzGYPH pxFHHH02M5k14lS0tihC6MghjYFCL7775PpLgGJEcpDhGQ/VrkkkB1EUgDMCFa3TBP8AGeE22NB2FK5Z+e0yIXT6h/rvZwyiIK0wZ0dAXdfdeMqT28SkXFb+Z9bqIui0Uiqsk2nhKlAx HUkKu1722BW3xB732DoqVxem5weCTUx6rKUxyOqPGsSqenoINW 6AMwIuTKQWNtwC3pJ0v0gxO2IimAyiVmIjxUy6uTQr965+uhby 93f4UHV0rjOYObJ01awRIbLLosiMCZVn64KeL3fshvsfCfUVYc F51i1TosUcpyijkLMqhY+pGJkRzf3ihvtcbGg6OlcXrudJNNLO 2pW0SCdo1jUN1khXJjHLlj1FwmLxtiRbw3xJafBzvG8qwiKfqm SSNkxQ9MRvHG0jMrFcLzRHvex7XFqC64lpHkTGOZ4DceOMRM1v QCVXX+6quLlUhgx1Ds47PIkTuPkzqSPwsKpeM/SCDoZJdOkyO8Ook07MiWZI4OsNQA5tgLoLEZXvZSATV7xrmmPS hTIHN43lbAA4RRtEskhuRcKZo/CLsQTYG1qCV+jZv53J/qQf8FP0bN/O5P8AUg/4aptFxrUvHrpQFyhk1EUMTmNYmaIkIS3vAsbA3a2+2NaoOeljj fr5s8ZlLoIunJFHDFDJM0qsxUlRMreFmyV1xubig6GbhheCSKW QydRWUsyqCAwt2UAbd68cD0borvIFEkrZOF3AsqxqAf3UX8Sap 5efo1ZV6MxLvLGLdL3o9bHw9hu4/jZoyD6E9rWqJreeOodOunEiFtRAs2SxkKj6mbTFDck3ZtPNYqD 7g3GQoO1pQUoFKUoFYtWaUGMaWrN6UGLUtWaXoIui4ZHEZCi2M rl3JZmJY/FibD0A2HkBUqlKBSlKBSlKBSlKBWjVaCOQqXQMUYMt/usOzD0Nb6UFceXNNcnoR3ZFQ+EbolsF+SkAgeR7Vuk4VCws0SE YNFYqPs2tlGP2Titx28IqXSgotVyVpGjKJBHGTlZkUBlyCqxBG 4uqIDYg2UWIsCN+h5ciSBYGXqIpJHVLPY3JuuZJFrm2+3rVtSg rf8mtLa3s8VsUW2C2xjOUaj0Cm5HoSbd6kPwuEm5ijJAQXKr2j bqRjt2V/EPQ7ipVKCufl3TGQynTxdRnSQvguZeMEI5a1yVBNj5Xrfr+FxT BRLGsgRgy5C+LDsw9CPWpVKCsn5Z0rli+niYsXLFlByLp03Jv3 JQBT8Nu1eU5U0gJI00QJIJOIuSrmVSfiHJe/wCsSe5q1pQQNVwLTyuJJII3dcSHZQWBQkpY99izW9LmsaXl7TR Mjx6eJGjTpoyooZI7k9NTa4W5O3berClBScY5TgninQIsbTpJG 0qKuYEhvJYnza1z6kC97VKXgGntHeCI9Fi8ZKL4HJyLpf3WJJN +9/jVjS9BVtyvpCjIdLBg7tIy9NMWdlKs5Ft2Kkgn0JqVNwuF8Mok bpm6XUeCwt4fTbapVKCGnCIQkiCJMJWZpFxGLs/vs47Em2/rXgcA0+IXoR4qxcDFdnNwX+ZBIJ8wan0oKyXljSM+baaEvctkU XLIsJCb2vfNVb5i/ei8saQYfwaH6s5J4FODF+pktxsc/Ff1JPnVnSgUpSgUrBNcVxXmFtRIYomdI9x4LiWc+ZWwZli+Koz MN7KhVnDoOI8zQwtgWzk/k48S/wCNyAD8L3PkDUJ+LaqT3IBGPWQNb8eoYmXz7K34VV6fTGBLW6K sfOSPSqx7jJyZJz+Nv3QO2wGC/ifh9z96R31LD4ZOwLD8R3oPU2qkyxl1kKeqvqkVh5jJYoo2v27 SD8RsfBMR763Sn97Uag/4z1Lh4mqDFNZoVUdlWFgB57AT2ravGT39t0LfAgp+N+s3+FB4T g7+Qilv6ajVR2/IyZXv8LfG+3r2Nl7w6lfQwal5FU+uDsLi/lg1/MV6bhf62i0sg9YioJPe+LoAB/XP9+2BJGneTU6U/wCfYvH8s5DJHfsdmB/vFBsg1JyCpqyHPaPVxAMfM4qBE57HcXFr/Opo106faQBx+tA2R+ZRwpHnsC57d60zyOFK6mNJYj3eNSQPPxw tk1r23Bf1IUC9bI9O8YDQu0sffpu2Rx73ikO5PoGJB8itBM0ev SUXRgbGxG4ZT+qymxVvgQDUmq6TSxzgSoSrWssqbOtibqb9wDe 6MLXG4uK96LWHIxyW6gF7j3ZFvbNfTfYr5EjuCCQnUpSgUpSgU pSgUpSgUpSgUpSgUrVqNUsYydlVR3ZiAB5dzt6VTT84RXIhin1 RGzHTR5op2NjIxVL7jwhiRcXFBfUrnV49POcdPEiEqWL6hr9Px FAHij3LZLIMSy/Ztvtao+rl1XXj076gKZgSr6eNUAWMKXVur1DmwLYkEbZHbA5B1 LNaqfW84aSIgPqIyxvZIyZHNjY2SMMxt57bedqr+OcGSNFaMNL LlZI9Q8kqSFvEykSlgvhVzkLEY7beE3HBNLGsStGcs1Ulz7z7b E+nfZRYL2AA2oIcfNHUV2hjBVASzSyRxhRa92AydQLHuo27XFN LDrJgrvKmnXc9ONM3KkXXN5RZWHmAn4+meYdEJXhQWV2YnqW3C RjMqf1lL9IFDsRf0FWPDNX1IwxGLXZWW98XVijAHzAZTY+YtQa tHrWD9KULnjkrJcLIoNmIB3UglbrcjxrubkCwqs4/4YxL5wMJL/sr9oPjeMyC3qR8CLMUClKUClKUClKUHN/SLrni4dO0ZCs3TjDMyoqdWVIS7MwIUASEknYW8qoeDcuTNGMJ4 ShAJEMxcMG3BkIQiS++7Z38rWrtuL8MTUQyQyDwSqytbuARa4P kR3B8iBXy2HlOOCTo6iFOqtys0eUZmXuZQEVlJsBn4LjHxnHAs HYwctSxXYdNdt2V+kSBv4jHEo/G351u4YBI/TMsuQF7w6kyxgdrMQAVPzUA2NibVRabgcIAZSVXYqz6ZZx+91o Cy3v8QPQVYxTEHFdbEx9Ov0Wv6GIo5B/H8BQX/wCjpR7urlPwdYGFvwRWPzv+dedHq2MrRSdN2VQxeO4A3AxkQli hN7jxHIK3a1VHs1/eMD/CTXall+eLDH+6pK6vpILT6DTpfZALqD32bqRjexPu/nQWR5d0/cQoh/WiHTYfJo7EfnWiVWgKWkeRHZU6clmbxHdkewY4i7MGLeENuLVE/SAfvrJJB/okJKkfvKkhNjtcMPQ1t0uncMWi0+DEWMuqcvJYkdgC7MNh4SyD YfAgJMcYhmjjj2SQP9XvaMqAc0H3V3ClR4bslrEnL1oRhPNEvu YxyAeSmQyKyj0F4g1vV29ajafUqGbpE6mY2DOCAieeJcArGvng Lsb9m71JUrACztlJK2+I8Uj2sEjW/YKNhfYAkn3moM6UY6qZR2ZIpCP2yXjY/isafkfU04zs0DD3hMgHycFGHxGJJ+ag+VetLFgJJZSoZ7Mxv4Y 0UbJkfuqMiT2uzHa9eIFM0iyn7OO5iv3ZiCpl+WLMq+oZj5igt KUpQKUpQKUpQKUpQadXq0iRnkdURRdndgqqPVmbYCoR40G+zhm k/qGMf602AP4XqyIv3quPLmn+7CqH1ivGfneOxv8AHvQQdfr9YSi RRwRtJkQZnkfFVFyWWMKL3KiwY+9e5tY1LTzzjT9TUSosyo7rA VjKrK2MSqyjO+9nOXmSu4BF9Ny5dlZdRqEKXxs4ewYWIvMrkg7 He+4HoKrIuU54niaOeN1hFliljYXB8mdXv4dyt1OJZtiCuAQeH cMiSMsydRpYJZ1kmJkmjMZXFBM93IAlSzXvdWPmAOj5VctpICd yUXInuzfec/Fmux+dU44frY3Y9GJ0IdU6cl3hWRg8iqkqqjgsBYlhayjEgEnf w3jQ00XSlg1SrEoCN0WkDp7q3MOQDeRvbtfYGgkcFY+2awX2Jj NttiEx289wBWriw/hDHzT9H4/DPVSxt+a7f9m+ngfFYRqpWZ41bUBWC9RSydMFOm638LlcXt5kv 3wud/GLe1xAEYsYxKd7J036mnBPYFpWxAPe5tvsQn6vfVQKeypPIP3l 6UY/C0z/AI29Kzy99iR5LLqVHwVdRKqj8AAPwrTx6fpCOfuImOQHcrIpQK P65iNvhfcgVN4RpDHCitu25YjzdiXc/wCszUGjUf8AjIf6HUf7+m/+zThe02qH+cQ/iYIx/wDEVjibYTQSHteSMn0zUMCfhlEo+bD0NeuCLdXlO3WcuAf1Aqx x/EXRFa3kXPbtQbeNj+DTf0Un+4akaQ+BP3V/wqFzCx9ndR70o6S/BpT0wfwyv8gasFAAFthQeqVgGs0ClKwTQZpWMqUGaj6zQpKuLq GANxfupHZlPdWFzuNxTX6rpxu+OWCs1rgXAFzudhVLHzpGw0mM bltUzKFbFTCUWRpBLc7EdGVdr3KG229B51fLzocoQslzuHkkhl t/TxbvbyDgk3N23quk45JGLahdZDfv7RBFqoT62Oku1+1rkeextc XsPNmmcoFmBMjqiAK/iLqzoV23VlRyH90hGsTY2hx886UlspkUDIrbqFiixRSu7qUGAU TKT3GNiSNwoQNNxeB/c1PDm7i5hK2I3Ia8nhI9DvUpOJIhuuq4aht3ACm34S9tqn+2aP UStEelJIMvC63JEblHxLCzBXBU2vi2xsaqm4jw8SRxx53kl6WO mM6KGxmObCMqCpOmmXMA7od7KSoSv0sG2PEISP8AR0QsPmS0gA 7+QO3fvQ9JwbpqtV/SK4jI8jaXpwsO+9j8+1V2v41potSNPhqSRLHG7dXVYqZIJZ1KW Y5m0QXEb3ba9jVlo/0dJIqqIJXZVdWYCRmDL1F+se5ZsPEFvfGxta1Bl+M/c6mn09vuowlmAO+0aDFD238Quex89ukUglodPI7sLGbVHAkd7e K8gF7HAIq/Ii1aIua4I2mTDpRaYyCRvABGEUuXeJTmiNY4sV8XcbMpac3NOl VcjMigMVOWQIITqm6kXAEfjyItjve29Bti4USQ079RgQQousSk eapc3PY3YsQe1u1buJSzKl9PEkj3HhkkMS28zkEc/wCzUU806a7ATISrBLLdizFsMUCglzkGBxvYqQbWNaeF80xyaSL UuOkJbALcuSxYoqriLuSRsAKDxH7cWDOq7fcjkRUPzyRnP4MPl U32vU/zdP7b/oqHp+bEl1CwwL1AY1laTxBBG5ZVKHEqxyUgglbb7kgqMaPnCKR prgokHV6kjlAI+mwU9Vb5R5bstwMlUnba4Tfa9T/N0/tv+is6lp2gkxAjlxbCzK4yAuu7ADc7dqjSc36VVLNMFxWR2BWQ MixFBIWUrdSvVjJBF7ODaxvWRzZpTlaZfBlfZtykvQYJt4yJSq WW5uyj7wuEjguqeVWkJODuTGGAUrGAFF9gTchm33sw9Lmxqt5f 4yNTEZAuFpZ47E3v0Znhy7Dvhe1tr1YmgzSuXPPkQgaUxvkk40 7ReHLqFkUG98cMZI3y9GG19quW47ApKvNErKUVlLrdWclUU/FiCB6kECgn0qmHNWnEjq2o04VbAHrJmX+sLqyfdsIj5m9m2GO8 2Li8LsUSaNnABxV1LWKhxsD+qyt8mB86CZSuZ0XPEbyOjqIhE8 qSM8sXg6ZxLsL3Cliig9yXG3e07X82aWKMyNPGVxDjFgxZSQql bd7kgfjQXFYxqtm5l0qEh9TApGNw0iAjIErsT5hWt64n0rRxrm E6cx2gaRZHijVlZAucrFFG5v5Ak+jDv5BZ6vRRyqUlRJFPdZFD KfLcNcVAk5W0xDBYVQN7wiLRBrixyEZUG4ABJ7gAdqj8O5vidp 1mKadoGsySyJliNPFqWdvIBRMQdyPATf0mx8xaVmCjUwlmtZRI mRuxQbXvu6svzBHeggQ8oqjBkn1F190TSdcJtbwdcMRsbXvcjz rZoeH6qAYrJDKgtgjo8ZQdsRIGe6jawKk9/EdraeMc6wwTrDcM+cCyXYKI1m6mLkm9/s+37S71bQ8YhYoqzRs0iZoqupLp3zWx3X4igpOIQamYMmohPTP ZdK8bm4IKs7TYE2IDhQvcWNwPFJ0nNCiy6iOWGQ3Hiik6bWAJd XUMoU+QZg3lb1Rc4QmWdD4E05ZZZpGRUQqFPjBOSA5+FiAGxa2 1i09ON6YhSJ4iHcxqRIlmcHEoLHdsiBbvcgUGnTZTyLKVZY0F4 w4xZmYEGQqd1AQ4gGx8b3A8NeOIaPWO/wBXqIo4/Jeixk+N5C+NvgEB2G/lWrjPNsEGmnnWSKToiTwCRAWkSMy9K+9nKre1ibb2q0n4jGgTq OiZkBc2AyY2AUX7kkgfMj1oK7R8M1Md8ZYjfuXXUOfzeUmpHS1 f8pp/7KT/AJlQI+cEK6uXE9LSGVXZTlIWivmBGB222ORvbcLUvRcxxvGJJC sKsyqpd4yshYKQY3UlXBLY3B7g0G0Rarzkg/CKT/mVG47ppmZekXHUVoWwZh08yrCbY2BUK4v3uy+W1SH5k0q2y1MI ve15EHuyCFu58pCEPoxt3qJxTmyGP2fBo5TqJY41CyLfF36ZkA 3LBW2I/wALGguwn/dzSvVKCPr9J1YnjyK5qy5AAkZCxIB27GqIcjxh1cSOCJes2y2d jC8DC1vCpE2ocgW8czGulpQcxHyDCIjGZZjZNLHG4KB4k0rF4A pxsSrO5yIJOXyrTrfo8jkaZutIqzRzRlFEdlWaCDTMFuL7JpYr fG/e+3W0oOQ5e5ami1TzyE+MzZKeiyfWOG+pKqHW+CFrnfEXBIBXd peQI0n64nmL9VZAT0ybj2nZiVuwx1sy3O4Cx2Ph36mlBz2t5OS TU+0CWRGzjkxAjKlo4ZIAd1vbCZtr9xWvgPIsWkdXSR2xjjSzC I3McS6dZMsMwelGikBgpte166WlByHM3JBnimIkeWUxaxYRJ0x i2pSRMTIFD9JRKQEuQLDuVW22XkOOUiSSSXrdRZC5EDfxSwmMo yGMrgo3xvcXBFdVSg5iDkKFGySSRSJjPGbRfVuxcuL4ZOrdaUW ctYN4cbCpEHJ8aaaCBZZL6aQSRytgXD3c+IBQpGMjra3Y+tjV/SgoOCcoJpZeokrkdIRFXCEECR5S5IAORklkY+W9gABWnWciRTE maWWS8U0QJKBwsxuwLhcmC/dU3A9CQCOlpQcrr/o+jmEmc82cy6hZZAIgXWdII2AUritl0sABA7Ke5N6f5AJkGM8p IMjKbRbO+sXX5+7vaZFsO1tiK6qlBX8F4MNMjIHd8pZpSXwvlN I0rAYgbZO1vnU81mlByk/0fxuDeaQO3TycBBfpze0L4LY3yCAta+KAXrc/IcDdXJ5D1BMFIIBi60w1MjR2HfrqJBe9iLdtq6WlBzGq5ER5+q JpEsqKEAQgBIJ9OpuwLE46qY7nvj6bxeXeUJNLqywZWiWMRqWU dQgRQRXDKwAY+zRZeAe4u52t2NKDno+T1EUydZ8pZWl6gWMOhe RJXVCF2UmNfjtsQQCIEP0aQrHh1pfshFkMFJAlEyFgoxbFhtcb AkdjXYUoOYTkSNZM1mkA9oXU42ht1Azu4ywzIZ5GaxJxv4cRtV pxvgntAiHUaPpSxyjEKbtGclByB2vVnSg5fiHIiSvI51EqmR5Z PAI/C0mlXReElT2jUEfH8q06b6O0QkjUS+J4ntaO14tZJr1Ha9urK/8AVsPK9ddSg5/iXJ6S6gT9WRGDadsVwKk6cylPeUkfbPff0rTwDkSLSSI8cshxi jiIYRWfpp0kcnDIEIApCkKcQSL101KDjua+STPHMyO0kxh1McI fpqF9oBBVnC5FFyNlJIHoSFtLh5HiEsc3UkEqSSSO1oj1DI6SM rBkIUXijAK4sAvfcmumpQcgfo0g6HQE0wULNGhAhDJDNF0Wi2T xeEL42u/hHi7g2nGeU49SEEjv4Y5ImtiOpFJ0zIjWG1zDGbixGO2xIq7pQ VGj5eEcc6LNIOtLLLmMQ8bSHIhNrbHtcH43qsk+jyBlcF3BkOo 6hQIgdNRGkU0eKrioKxRbizZLe5ya/VUoOVn5AjaRXE8y4ySSKo6RUNJq4tewN1uR1oU8/d2+NeYfo8iVkYTzXWRJD9l42TUy6pA10NgH1Mw2sSGF+166ylA pSlApSlApSlApSlApSlApSlApSlApSlApSlApSlApSlApSlApS lApSlApSlApSlApSlApSlApSlApSlApSlB//9k=[/IMG]
__________________
Paul Elliott, S/V VALIS - Pacific Seacraft 44 #16 - Friday Harbor, WA
www.sailvalis.com
Paul Elliott is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15-03-2013, 13:02   #45
Registered User

Join Date: Dec 2012
Posts: 449
Re: Doppler Effect or Not?

Quote:
Originally Posted by jongleur View Post
Don't believe everything you think.
Good one ... and ...

I don't, otherwise I would go nuts ...
Richard_W is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off


Advertise Here


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 16:07.


Google+
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Social Knowledge Networks
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.

ShowCase vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.