Frantz Oil Cleaning System

[GordMay]

Originally Posted by Chief Engineer

Oh, Good Grief!!!!

Indeed!
On what basis would we decide to add an aftermarket product of unknown formulation, to a fuel of unknown (& likely changing /w brand) formulation?
Additive manufacturer’s claims?
Anecdotal testimonials, of unknown provenance?

[Lancerbye]

Originally Posted by GordMay

Indeed!
On what basis would we decide to add an aftermarket product of unknown formulation, to a fuel of unknown (& likely changing /w brand) formulation?
Additive manufacturer’s claims?
Anecdotal testimonials, of unknown provenance?

On the basis of blatent consumerism? LOL

[Alan Wheeler]

Unfortunately Chiefs "Good Grief" is a little out of context due to several posts before hand having to be removed.

[Pelagic]

Perhaps I'm missing something here but that means you are in the ER every couple of days changing oil soaked Toilet paper?

Or on a 20 day passage, 20 of them have accumulated awaiting disposal

Good Grief!

[Crest25]

Unfortunately, I cannot fully explain some misconceptions and total outright myths without approaching the merchandising line of this group. I will be happy to explain the error off line without any sales gimmick or inticement to purchase.
To say you would be hauling rolls of TP in the bilges on a 20-day cruise is just crazy. Obviously you haven't done any homework. So before I sail off into the sunset and leave this crazy discussion to those who 1) have never tried it, 2) listen to those who have never tried it, or 3) just want to post incorrect concepts, let me assure you I've used it since 1960 including in marine situations and ask your grandfather if it works. He probably was a consumer.
So long.
Ed
crest25 at verizon.net

[Roy M]

A little off-topic, I suppose, but that hasn't stopped me yet: My Yanmar 3GM30 uses a "side-loading" oil filter, guaranteed to make a horrific mess when changing oil in the cramped space of my tiny engine compartment. At the suggestion of some hot rod friends, I installed a FRAM HP-1 system on an accessible bulkhead, and replaced the original filter with the included pickup plate. Hoses were custom made at a nearby marine supplier. Now, I just place a plastic baggie, after loosening the filter, around the old element, spin it off and dispose of it at the oil waste station. I suppose I could use it longer than the 50 hour schedule, but I haven't yet. I have just achieved the 56 hour point, having changed the oil at the 25 hour reading. I will be keeping the oil analysis records from each oil change to see if there is any unusual stuff going on.

[never monday]

Originally Posted by Crest25

Unfortunately, I cannot fully explain some misconceptions and total outright myths without approaching the merchandising line of this group. I will be happy to explain the error off line without any sales gimmick or inticement to purchase.
To say you would be hauling rolls of TP in the bilges on a 20-day cruise is just crazy. Obviously you haven't done any homework. So before I sail off into the sunset and leave this crazy discussion to those who 1) have never tried it, 2) listen to those who have never tried it, or 3) just want to post incorrect concepts, let me assure you I've used it since 1960 including in marine situations and ask your grandfather if it works. He probably was a consumer.
So long.
Ed
crest25 at verizon.net

many thousands of engines have endured thousands of hours with OE oil filters

Originally Posted by Roy M

A little off-topic, I suppose, but that hasn't stopped me yet: My Yanmar 3GM30 uses a "side-loading" oil filter, guaranteed to make a horrific mess when changing oil in the cramped space of my tiny engine compartment. At the suggestion of some hot rod friends, I installed a FRAM HP-1 system on an accessible bulkhead, and replaced the original filter with the included pickup plate. Hoses were custom made at a nearby marine supplier. Now, I just place a plastic baggie, after loosening the filter, around the old element, spin it off and dispose of it at the oil waste station. I suppose I could use it longer than the 50 hour schedule, but I haven't yet. I have just achieved the 56 hour point, having changed the oil at the 25 hour reading. I will be keeping the oil analysis records from each oil change to see if there is any unusual stuff going on.

are you still in warranty?
if so I'd revert to the OE until your out of warranty.

[Alan Wheeler]

and ask your grandfather if it works. He probably was a consumer.

Actually it was my Grandfather who was a very highly qualified Mechanic, that I learn't that this sort of thing is not good. Maybe it is a case of loo paper rolls were different in those days.

[JiffyLube]

Originally Posted by GordMay

Indeed!
On what basis would we decide to add an aftermarket product of unknown formulation, to a fuel of unknown (& likely changing /w brand) formulation?
Additive manufacturer’s claims?
Anecdotal testimonials, of unknown provenance?

I though most people were commenting on their experiences with this filter. I'm not sure anyone advocated using it.

[Roy M]

nevermonday, I'm long out of warranty, I just took a while getting all of the engine support systems completed before ignition. My local engine gurus (all very experienced marine guys) concurred with my judgement and decision. We'll see what the test of time and oil analysis tell us.

[never monday]

Originally Posted by Roy M

nevermonday, I'm long out of warranty, I just took a while getting all of the engine support systems completed before ignition. My local engine gurus (all very experienced marine guys) concurred with my judgement and decision. We'll see what the test of time and oil analysis tell us.

I don't like the added resistance and length of flow.
You can easily solve the dripping issue when changing filter with a 1 gal ziplock bag. Even in the stock location

[fcsob]

As a ASE certified master tech of 35 years I can't believe that those are still for sale. If you have metal filing in your oil you have a real problem. Why does your oil get dirty? Combustion. Heat & shear to your oil. Put your money into a high quality symthetic oil & use good oil filters don't wast your $ on voodoo.

[Roy M]

never monday, you make several assumptions that, unfortunately, don't enter into my solution. One, that the friction and length of flow are significant. They are not, the hose diameters are large, and lengths are short. Two, that one would waste a bunch of money when a simple solution as a plastic bag would suffice. I tried it, found the space too constricted to swing a filter wrench, easily manipulate the bag, wait for the system to drain adequately, then clean up the oil that inevitably leaks, and then discover the joys of working blind in tight quarters to spin a new cylinder on and tighten it adequately. I wanted a system that any member of my crew could maintain, that had the necessary degree of dependability, and that reassured me that adequate lubrication was going to occur for the sizeable investment I had already made in the engine, the preparation of the compartment, and the intended use of the engine. Third, your comment about a "stock" location brings a smile to my face, and possibly others', since the curious arrangement of many boats is not "stock", the position of an oil filter, or a dipstick, or any number of other parts on an engine can often be in a location that takes a double-jointed yoga master to engage. I'm sorry it makes you feel ill at ease. It did, also, for me. So I created a workable and satisfying solution for myself. Maybe it will work for someone else, that is the reason, I believe, for this forum - the exchange of ideas, novel solutions to common problems, and support.